Is Johnny Weir an upgrade from Ashley Banjo as a judge on Dancing on Ice?

Is Johnny Weir an upgrade from Ashley Banjo as a judge on Dancing on Ice?

Whether Johnny Weir is an "upgrade" from Ashley Banjo as a judge on Dancing on Ice depends on your perspective and priorities. Here's a breakdown of both sides:

Arguments for Johnny Weir:

Figure skating expertise: As a two-time Olympian and renowned figure skater, Weir brings immense knowledge and technical understanding of the sport, allowing him to provide detailed and specific feedback to contestants.

Fresh perspective: Coming from a different background than the other judges, Weir can offer a unique viewpoint and potentially challenge established norms, fostering creativity and growth among contestants.

Entertainment value: Known for his flamboyant personality and fashion sense, Weir can add a touch of humor and excitement to the judging panel, enhancing the show's entertainment factor.

Arguments for Ashley Banjo:

Dance expertise: As a professional dancer and choreographer, Banjo possesses a strong understanding of movement and performance, offering valuable insights on artistry and expression beyond figure skating techniques.

Experience with the show: Having been a judge on Dancing on Ice for several seasons, Banjo is familiar with the show's format, scoring system, and contestant dynamics, ensuring consistency and smooth judging experience.

Rapport with contestants: Banjo is known for his encouraging and supportive approach, building positive relationships with contestants and creating a more nurturing environment.

Ultimately, whether Johnny Weir is an "upgrade" is subjective and depends on what you value most in a judge. Some might prioritize technical expertise and a fresh perspective, while others might prefer familiarity with the show and a supportive demeanor.

Additional factors to consider:

The specific episode or season: Weir is currently a temporary guest judge, so a direct comparison with Banjo's full-time involvement might not be entirely fair

Audience preferences: Fan reactions to Weir's judging have been generally positive, but some viewers might miss Banjo's presence and style.

It's best to observe their judging styles and contributions to the show before forming your own opinion on who you prefer.